10 Expert Tips

New: Major Scales for Piano for free download!

A thorough study of piano scales is vital to playing musically and with confidence. Nonetheless, while virtually all piano music has scales literally left and right, all too many students view scales as needless tedium rather than essential elements of music’s expressive vocabulary. Here are 10 practice tips for students and teachers:

1. Begin with the black keys (B major, D-flat, G-flat). The five black keys promote a natural position of the hand, since the longer fingers play the shorter (i.e., black) keys and vice versa. Chopin always started his students with these keys and ended with C major as the most physically difficult. Unfortunately, nowadays C major is almost without exception the first piano scale learned, since the most difficult to play is also the easiest to read. However, even Vladimir Horowitz made this observation about C major: With his reputation as the greatest virtuoso of his time (his sheer variety of touch at all speeds has hardly been excelled), whenever interviewers asked him to name the most difficult piece he ever played, he would offer one of two replies, either Liszt’s startlingly difficult etude ‘Feux follets’ or the C major scale. He wasn’t being entirely facetious.

2. Practice chromatically rather than through the circle of fifths. Chromatic progression has the advantage that the fingers are forced to adjust to a very different pattern from one scale to the next. Similarly, it’s useful to practice parallel keys side-by-side. Thus, a great daily warm-up is: D-flat major, C-sharp minor; D major, D minor; E-flat major, E-flat minor, etc. Alternatively, you can progress backwards chromatically starting with B major and ending with C, as per Chopin’s suggestion.

3. Always practice musically! This point cannot be stressed enough. It is absolutely vital that the mind and emotions be connected with your fingers at all times. There is no such thing as “just” a scale or “just” an arpeggio. Practicing musically means varying your touch and articulation, the intensity of the sound, and sometimes even the tempo within a scale. Thus, crescendo and decrescendo as well as accelerando and ritardando, however subtle, are all expressive means that belong in the scale practice regimen of every pianist. Experiment with communicating various emotions simply through piano scales. Piano scales are at particular risk of sounding mechanical, and we need to do everything to make them as musical as possible.

4. Develop an accurate inner pulse. Practicing scales is one of the few areas in which regularly practicing with a metronome is desirable. The vast majority of pianos students play scales very unevenly, and they cannot hear their unevenness. The metronome is therefore useful for correcting this problem. Nonetheless, it’s important not to have to rely on it. Subtle, controlled fluctuations in tempo are very often a desirable effect. Musicians need to be equipped both to play strictly in time and to deviate from absolute time in a beautifully controlled manner. For scale practice, rhythmic evenness should be given by far the greatest emphasis. (I actually had to practice, rather extensively at that, playing scales unevenly to achieve a desired effect, only to be criticized by a colleague for “not having practiced my scales”!)

5. Never play too fast. Evenness is much more important than speed. Speed will come over time, all by itself, given proper concentration and regular work. Velocity is in any case never an end in itself, no matter how “showy” the music.

6. You can’t force anything. Attempting to “force” your way to play something before your mind and body are able will always backfire. Thus, practicing scales slowly and evenly, without any excessive tension, will pave the way much more quickly to brilliant scales than will trying to play too fast too soon.

7. Use the thumb properly. A true, literal legato connection can only be achieved in slow to moderate tempi. At faster speeds trying to play legatissimo creates an awkward manipulation of the playing mechanism that inhibits muscular freedom. Instead, listen very carefully (as always!) to match the articulation of each and every note, without any unnecessary tension. More legato will come over time when practicing this way; however, a perfect legato is not necessarily desirable in the fastest tempos—only a legato effect.

8. Practice different rhythmic groups. Practice piano scales first in quarter notes, then eighths, then eighth-note triplets, then sixteenths. Even slightly accenting every fifth note can be a challenging change of pace for advanced students.

9. Look straight ahead! It’s important to develop proper proprioception. That’s a complicated word that simply means the awareness of the body in space, something that athletes and dancers have to often an astonishing degree. Musicians need this faculty as well, and the less we rely on watching our hands, the more secure becomes our playing. This strategy has auxiliary benefits as well: Not only is looking up better for posture and muscular freedom (and hence tone production), but closing our eyes allows our minds to focus more on the sound, for the simple reason that there’s less “processing” for our brains to do.

10. Practice regularly. Regular practice will accomplish significantly more in the long run than will general neglect interspersed with occasional heavy scale practice. I find that scales make for the best warm-up, both for the fingers and for the mind and ear. It’s therefore recommendable to start off a practice session by carefully going through scales in all keys. As long as you work consistently it will take only a few minutes to keep the mechanism in shape.

By adhering to these guidelines you’ll be certain to gain not just proficiency in piano scales but greater freedom of expression from your playing in general.

  • Ronaldo José Groto

    Hi, Frantz. Thanks for the wonderful tips
    I am about to start practicing scales daily. How do you suggest I use the metronome? Number of beats per minute, for example.

    • http://www.key-notes.com/ Albert Frantz

      Hi Ronaldo, depending on your level, I suggest starting with 2 notes per beat, 2 octaves up and down, then 3 notes per beat, 3 octaves up and down, and finally 4 notes per beat, 4 octaves up and down.

      The number of beats per minute should never exceed your ability to play with even articulation and dynamics. I find that sometimes practicing slower (for me, 132 or 138 BPM with 4 notes per beat, rather than 160 or 168) brings me greater control and I feel that it brings me an equivalent benefit for my fingers in terms of warming them up. If you’re at a beginning to intermediate level, 88 to 100 BPM will be plenty fast. Just remember that you’ll benefit far more by learning to control your fingers by developing evenness of touch at a slower speed.

      If you want to build speed and articulation quickly, I recently published a course called Mastering Piano Scales as part of the membership.

  • John Holt

    Should you practice the left hand and right hand separately when playing scales or together?

    • http://www.key-notes.com/ Albert Frantz

      When first learning the scales, it’s best to practice mostly hands separately since otherwise it’s too easy not to hear unevenness. Once you’re comfortable with the scales and can play them evenly, then I recommend practicing hands together. At that point I only go back to hands separate scale practice if I notice any unevenness.