Writing in Fingerings
Question: I am returning to playing the piano after 20 years. I took lessons from the age of 8 until I was 17. My problems are fingering, sight reading and arthritic fingers. It's a real struggle. When I play a piece each time I use different fingers which really complicates the situation. I'm getting discouraged. I think maybe I should go back to more beginners' pieces. Thank you.
Christine (Topeka, Kansas, USA)
Albert's reply: There is a very simple solution to your problem: Write in your fingerings. You should be able to look at any measure of your music and know instantly which note is to be played with which finger. If you're unsure in the slightest, you need to write in your fingerings.
The purpose of writing in your fingerings is clarity. Obsessively writing every single fingering in every piece of music can be counterproductive; in some pieces this practice impedes clarity and will interfere with learning music. The fingering for many passages will be obvious. While Liszt's music is among the most physically complex, very often—I dare say even most of the time—the fingering is self-evident; there is often only one option. In such cases, writing in every last finger number will sometimes make the music harder to read rather than easier.
There is one exception, fugues. The fugues of Bach are especially complex and they are enormous challenges for the memory. There is no room for any uncertainty, and writing in all fingerings in a fugue will provide the utmost clarity.
I learned this technique of writing in fingerings from Jörg Demus, who has the most astonishing memory of any pianist I've ever witnessed. Even in his eighties, Demus is able to play any work of Bach, Schumann, Debussy and other composers perfectly from memory. While it is clear that he has an unusual gift, he insists that he cultivated it through this technique of writing in fingerings and keeping his eyes on the score during practice. This is the way to reinforce the visual memory of your music.
(Note: I'm afraid I can't address problems of arthritis, as I have neither the experience nor the qualifications to do so.)
Related lessons
- Piano Fingering
- Piano fingering is one of the most crucial aspects of learning the instrument, yet it is among the most overlooked. Here are seven of the most important...
- Finger Numbers
- Question: I can read notes but I don't know which finger I'm going to use with that note. I just wish to have sheet music with finger number on every note or...
- Changing Fingerings
- Question: When sight reading new music by professional piano players, are the fingering positions subject to interpretation or are the fingerings 'set in...
- Developing Fingering Confidence
- Question: I am a senior citizen who has dreamed of learning to play the piano since childhood. I have learned a lot on my own, and started taking lessons two...
- Fingering Myths or Facts?
- Question: My question is, how important is 'correct' fingering when playing? I recently downloaded (THANK YOU) your scales reference, which showed all...
- Are Editorial Fingerings Compulsory?
- Question: Is it essential to play or to require my students to play all indicated fingerings in early advanced pieces, i.e., Chopin's Fantasie-Impromptu Op....
© 2013 key-notes LLC | Legal | Privacy Policy
All rights reserved worldwide