Learn like a Concert Pianist

... even if you're a complete beginner

Conservatory-quality online piano lessons from the City of Music, Vienna, Austria

Start Your NEW Piano Journey
Back to Blog

Brahms 51 Exercises

piano technique

Question: Any fingering suggestions for Exercise 1a and 1b?

– Mike (Dallas, Texas, USA)

Albert’s reply: This exercise is designed to be played with a consistent fingering, even though it breaks the rule of avoiding the thumb on black keys.

The reason is that it’s not a finger exercise per se but rather a rhythm exercise. Brahms’s purpose was to train the fingers to play 4 against 3, and there’s no need for the added difficulty of complicated fingerings.

I recommend the following fingerings:

Consistent fingerings for sequential passages are also an important memory aid. Although ordinarily the thumb would never be passed on a black key, in such cases it might make sense since the music becomes much easier to learn and remember.

Also, as this is a rhythmic exercise, it’s a good idea to practice it with a metronome, at least in the beginning. Triplet eighths in the context of sixteenth notes are almost invariably played too fast, and tapping in sync with a metronome is the only cure short of having a teacher correct your rhythm.

Start Your NEW Piano Journey

Let's stay in touch so I can help you achieve your dream of playing piano as effortlessly and beautifully as possible.

I'll send you occasional lessons and updates to help you along your path.

Your teacher,


We will never sell your information, for any reason.